Our Menu

Breakfast  |  Lunch & Dinner  |  Kids Menu  |  Desserts  |  Beverages


(Breakfast menu served until 11:00 a.m.)

Annie’s Hash – our signature breakfast casserole served with Michael’s Homestyle toast 7.50

Homemade Quiche of the Day- made daily in our kitchen with the best local ingredients  6.00

Pioneer Skillet – a hearty breakfast of fried potatoes, 3 eggs, choice of meat : 3 sausage links, bacon or ham; smoked cheddar cheese and a slice of toast (from Michael’s Homestyle Breads)  8.99

Pioneer Wrap – a more portable version of the Pioneer Skillet – with mayo and  Ham, Bacon or Sausage  6.79

Our own Dried Beef Gravy with your choice of a Biscuit or Michael’s Toast  6.50

House-made Baked Oatmeal with Steamed Milk  5.00

Avocado Toast Topped with Feta and Tomatoes  7.50 (add a hard-boiled egg for .75)

Baked French Toast with Berries & Cream – made with Michael’s cinnamon swirl bread  7.50

Fruit, Granola and Pequea Valley Farms Yogurt Parfait  4.09

Fruit, Granola and Fiddle Creek Dairy Greek Yoghurt Parfait   5.09

Nutella Toast  – coconut, banana and chia seeds available

Kids Breakfast – 1 scrambled egg, Choice of toast, Fresh Fruit  3.70

Kid’s Yogurt – Vanilla Yogurt with our homemade jam and berries – 1.95



Scrapple or Sausage – Stoltzfus Meats  2.99

Berries & Cream – fresh fruit topped with Freda’s signature cream sauce  2.99

Toast – from Michael’s Bakery – with Strawberry Jam on request  1.69
(Cinnamon Raisin, Honey Whole Wheat, Potato White, Cinnamon Swirl, or Garlic Rye)

Apple Cider Donuts – fresh, house-made, using Kauffman’s Apple Cider .69 each  :  1/2 dozen 3.50   : dozen  6.50

Muffins, Flops, Energy Balls, Bread Pudding and other tasty items made in house by our baker, Tracy

Prices and offerings may change without notice

Lunch & Dinner


We usually have 3 or 4 hot soups available. Daily soups can be found on our Facebook page. Be sure to check out our cooled  Soup section in the refrigerator by the soda fountain for soups that are not on the daily list. Daily soups can also be purchased by the quart while available.  We don’t use flour to thicken our soups, so most of our soups – those without pasta or barley- are gluten free or can be gotten gluten free if ordered without croutons.  While we use many Gluten-Free Recipes, we are not a Gluten-Free Facility. Those marked with V are vegetarian. Our staff will happily let you know which of our daily options are most suitable for you.

Crock of Soup (12oz) in house or to go  $4.99    (up charge for seafood/mushroom soups)

Soup Sampler – perfect when you just can’t decide … choose 3 of our available soups $5.25

Quart of Soup to go only:  (32oz) – $11.69    Seafood/Mushroom soups- $14.50

We have Glass Quarts available for $1.00. If you return it with your next soup quart purchase (in like new condition) you can skip the glass jar fee.


Chicken Corn, Chili, Italian Sausage, Tomato Bisque, Mushroom Barley, Cream of Mushroom, Seafood Chowder, Cream of Mushroom (V), Creamy Chicken Chili, Tomato Dill (V), Chicken Noodle, Beef Barley, Italian Wedding Soup, Beef Vegetable, Old Fashioned Potato, Loaded Potato, Pepper Jack Tomato (V), Buffalo Chicken Chili, Cream of Crab, Cabbage Vegetable (V), Corn Chowder (V), Minestrone (V), Cheddar Broccoli (V) and more.

Our Tomato soups are usually served with our signature grilled cheese croutons.


Caesar Wedge Salad  6.49

Bleu Cheese Wedge – using our homemade Bleu Cheese Dressing   6.49

Hot Bacon Wedge – made with our own Hot Bacon Dressing   8.29

Taco Salad 8.29 (only available seasonally)

Garden Salad – mixed greens, carrots, tomatoes and choice of cheese & dressing   6.49

Mild Boneless Wings on a Bed of Greens  8.29
Served with Bleu Cheese or Ranch Dressing

Deli Garden Salad – topped with Egg Salad, Tuna Salad, or Curry Chicken Salad  8.49

Brisket on Spinach Salad – our house-smoked Brisket, feta, candied pecans, craisins and house balsamic vinaigrette on a bed of fresh spinach

Combos & Samplers

Cup of Soup and Half Garden Salad combo  7.59

Quiche & Greens Combo (while it lasts!)  9.25

Quiche & Soup Combo (while it lasts!)  9.25

Soup Sampler – perfect when you just can’t decide … choose 3 of our available soups

Deli Salad Sampler – choose 3 of our house-made meat salads: Curried Chicken, Tuna, Egg or Ham on a romaine leaf with crackers (GF crackers available)

(You can add a Michael’s Homestyle roll, a croissant, or piece of cornbread to your meal)


Deli Salad Wrap      Your choice of our seasonal Deli Salads, Romaine lettuce & Tomato wrapped in a Flour Tortilla, served with a Dill Pickle Spear and Zerbes Chip 8.29

Burger Wrap     ¼# Angus Beef, Romaine lettuce & Tomato wrapped in a Flour Tortilla, served with a Dill Spear and Zerbes Chips. Upgrade your wrap with Bacon, Bleu Cheese or our House BBQ Sauce  8.29


Baked Potato Topped with our feature Chili, Sour Cream, and Cheese or occasionally Broccoli Cheddar Soup or another of Freda’s creations.  7.29

Baked Potato with Butter  3.49

Loaded Sweet Potato with Honey Cinnamon Butter and Candied Pecan Baked Sweet Potato with Butter  5.69


Brisket Stack over Fries


Our Signature Mac & Cheese  5.69

“Mac Stack” – Mac & Cheese topped with boneless wings, tossed in your choice of wing sauce  7.29
(Mild Buffalo Sauce, Asian Sesame, House-made BBQ, Carolina Style or Plain)

Brisket Stack – House-smoked brisket served over your choice of mac & cheese, french fries, baked potato, or sweet potato fries  10.49

Creamy Brisket Cassoulet – Our House-Smoked Brisket & Broth, Fusilli, house white sauce, smoked cheddar, parmesan and crispy onions  13.25

Brisket Nachos – mouth-watering queso with our house-smoked Brisket on a bed of Nachos  5.95

“Build-Your-Own” – A scoop of Curry Chicken Salad, Tuna Salad, or Egg Salad  5.73
Served with your choice of a white or wheat roll or with a croissant (upcharge)

Deconstructed Meals to be eaten with a Fork

Reuben on Rye – grilled & cubed Rye, Corn Beef, Kraut, house-made Thousand Island, topped with Swiss Cheese & Broiled

Tuna on Rye – grilled & cubed Rye, Tuna Salad,  topped with Swiss Cheese & broiled

Burger Stack – Grilled and cubed Brioche, 1/4 Pound Angus Burger, topped with your choice of Bacon, Cheddar or Bleu Cheese & Broiled


  House-Smoked Chicken – 8.99       House-Smoked Brisket –  9.99     Cheese Quesadilla – 7.99
Served with sour Cream and our house Salsa on the Side

Only After 4pm

Brisket & Cheesy Potato Platter – House-Smoked Brisket, Cheesy Potatoes, Michaels Roll, choice of House Slaw or Side Salad  12.29

Sweet Potato Fries with House-made Aioli

Appetizers & Sides

Sweet Potato Fries with Aioli  4.29

Brew City French Fries 3.89

Mozzarella Sticks  4.99

Crock of Mac & Cheese  3.79

Nacho Bowl – Organic Corn Nachos with your choice of scooping dip – house salsa, house corn & bean salsa (seasonal), house chili, or brisket queso   4.99

Boneless Wings tossed in choice of sauce  6.49 (Mild Buffalo, Our House BBQ, House Carolina or Asian Sesame Sauce) with Ranch or Bleu Cheese Dressing

Onion Petals with House-made Aoili   4.99

Prices and offerings may change without notice

Kids Menu

Kids platters come with juice box, chips and choice of applesauce, grapes or carrots w/ranch 5.50

Mac & Cheese Platter – our signature dish in a kid portion

PBJ Platter – Classic Peanut Butter with Strawberry Jam between 2 soft slices of Michael’s Homestyle bread

Boneless Wing Chicken Platter –  real meat chicken 

Cup of Soup Platter – your choice of our daily soup specials

BYO Brisket Platter 6.50  – Brisket with a Michael’s Homestyle Roll



Soft Serve Ice Cream – vanilla

Chocolate, Caramel or Peanut Butter Sundaes

Root Beer and Soda Floats




Apple Cider Donut Sundae


A wide variety of baked goods – muffins, cupcakes, cookies, pies, mini cheesecakes, whoopee pies, Bundt cakes, and more. We also offer gluten-free desserts in addition to some sugar-free options. 

Prices and offerings may change without notice


House Coffee – Lancaster County Coffee Roasters StarBarn Blend

House-brewed, Unsweetened Ice Tea

Fountain Soda (Coke products)

Boylan Root Beers & Cream Soda

HumanKind Teas & Lemonades

Shrub – by Christina’s Pantry – Strawberry and Red Raspberry

Baba’s Brew Kombucha – a selection of season flavors

Orange Juice

Maplehofe Dairy Milk products: chocolate, white, strawberry or eggnog
(depending on the season)

Kauffman’s Apple Cider- Seasonal – Mulled Apple Cider

Specialty Drinks

We offer a selection of Monin Syrups. We use Lancaster County Coffee Roasters Red Rose Espresso beans – freshly ground for each cup.





London Fog

Chai Latte

Our Signature Hot Cocoa – with whipped cream or our own homemade marshmallows

Tasty Seasonal Drinks

We’re please to carry 12oz bags of Lancaster County Coffee Roaster Coffee in a variety of roasts:

Star Barn Regular and Decaf in both Ground and Whole Bean; Regular also as French Press

Other roasts include Breakfast Blend, Lancaster Signature and Fasnacht Blend

We also carry Simply Ghee – Original, Black Garlic, Turmeric and Black Pepper and Sriracha

Prices and offerings may change without notice